Consultation Responses
Comments on the Guidance for Completing the Port Facility Vulnerability Assessment Template
Danish Ports acknowledges the opportunity to submit comments on the guidelines for completing the port facility vulnerability assessment template.
The guidelines for completing the port facility vulnerability assessment template, as well as the port facility vulnerability assessment itself, are intended to protect international maritime traffic, ports, and port facilities—a goal that Danske Havne supports.
General
Danske Havne generally emphasizes that the introduction of the new template for port facility vulnerability assessments should not result in disproportionately high financial and/or administrative implementation costs for the ports, as Version 4 includes significantly more new measures compared to Version 3.
Specific changes:
Regarding major changes, page 8:
The text states that in the event of major changes—including“the establishment of property or infrastructure […] on a neighbor’s property adjacent to the port” and“the facility undergoing a renovation”—a new vulnerability assessment must be prepared. Taken together, Danske Havne believes that there is a risk of over-implementation if the port facility is required to prepare a new vulnerability assessment every time property or infrastructure […] is established on a neighbor’s property adjacent to the port or every time the port facility undergoes a renovation. Danske Havne believes that vulnerability assessments should only be required when the change has a real impact on a port facility’s vulnerability. Danske Havne proposes that the phrases“at a neighbor of the port”and“the facility undergoes a renovation” be further clarified or deleted.
Regarding major changes, page 45:
The text indicates that the proposed wording carries a significant risk that vulnerability assessments could become standard even for minor renovations or renovations that do not affect the facility’s vulnerability. Therefore, Danske Havne proposes that the text be clarified to include only renovations that result in significant changes to the port facility’s physical structure and are relevant to the facility’s vulnerability, or that the text be deleted.
Regarding minor changes, page 27:
The text states: “If IT systems are outsourced, an assessment of the external suppliers’ security level must also be included.”Danske Havne finds it unclear who, in this situation, is responsible for assessing the external supplier’s security level. Danske Havne proposes that this be clarified.
Sincerely,
Danish Ports, Iben Birk